Creamy cheddar with four peppers: a slow, sneaky burn.
Milton Creamery's Four Alarm Cheddar from Iowa, a creamy cow's milk cheddar blended with jalapeño, habanero, ghost chili, and chipotle. Order online.
We’ll keep track of cheeses you love and send you new finds that match your taste.
By saving, you agree to receive curated emails from The Cheese Store. Unsubscribe anytime.
Already have an account? Sign in for a faster experience →
You’ll hear from us when we find more like this one.
Four Alarm Cheddar comes out of Milton Creamery in Milton, Iowa, a small family-run dairy in the southeast corner of the state. The base is a young pasteurized cow's milk cheddar, semi-soft and buttery, and the creamery blends in four different peppers before the curd is pressed: jalapeño, habanero, ghost chili, and chipotle.
The paste is creamy and pliable, not crumbly, with bright flecks of red and green pepper running all the way through. The first bite reads as a clean, mild cheddar with that fresh-cream sweetness, and then the heat starts to climb. It's a sneaky burn, medium at the front and slow to build, with the chipotle adding a smoky backbone underneath the brighter chili notes. By the finish you understand the name.
The cheddar holds up, the peppers stay in balance, and the heat lands as a long finish rather than a punch. Great on a melt, a burger, or shaved into tacos.
Creamy and pliable for a cheddar, semi-soft under the knife with visible flecks of pepper running through the paste. Closer to a young farmhouse cheddar than a crumbly aged block.
Big personality driven by the pepper blend more than the cheddar itself. The cheese tastes mild and buttery up front, then the heat climbs.
A slow-building heat that lingers on the back of the palate well after the cheese is gone, with smoky chipotle pulling the longest.
A clean buttery cheddar base underneath the peppers, with the kind of fresh-cream sweetness that keeps the heat in check.
A faint toasted note from the cheddar paste, but the peppers are doing most of the talking.
A little smoky earthiness from the chipotle, otherwise the profile leans bright and peppery rather than cellar-aged.
Four peppers stacked together: jalapeño, habanero, ghost chili, and chipotle. The burn is sneaky, medium at first bite and then climbing into a real four-alarm finish.
Waxed rind
Wax-coated, inedible. The rind is purely a protective seal, so all of the flavor is in the paste.
Cheddar stands on its own, but the right partners turn a wedge into a moment. Regional pairings first — they were built for each other.
Cold beer and off-dry whites tame the chili heat, while a fruit-forward Zinfandel echoes the smoky chipotle note.
Sweet tropical fruit and honey cool the chili burn, and a bright acid like lime or tomato jam keeps the cheese from feeling heavy.
Video represents style and type of cheese - may not be an exact match in all cases.
Real reviews from The Cheese Store of Beverly Hills Google Business Profile. Curated by Dom and his team since 1967.
Domenico and his team are fantastic. I’m a chef and I often get my supplies from The Cheese Store — unique products, carefully selected, from top Italian and French cheeses to excellent local ones.
Absolutely loved the cheese store! Everyone was super helpful and friendly. Lena helped us — she was very knowledgeable on all the cheeses: where they came from, what the region is like, what they are known for. It was like wine tasting for cheese.
Ordered several cheeses from them and the wrong items were delivered. Contacted the store and they recognized the error and immediately sent the correct order the next day without any fuss. Really appreciate the promptness and professionalism.
“A Mennonite-run creamery built around a tight web of nearby Amish Jersey-milk farms, focused on stirred-curd cheddar aged long enough to develop true crystal crunch.”
Stirred-curd white cheddar made from neighboring Amish Jersey milk and aged on-site until calcium-lactate crystals form.
Hand-cut to order the day it ships. Packed cold for overnight delivery.
Taste it for yourself →Cold-ship 2-day overnight nationwide
